Discovering Charlotte County’s Amish Heritage: A Journey to Country Corner Dairy
Just before the festive season of Christmas, I had the pleasure of exploring the quaint Amish community nestled within Charlotte County, Virginia. This community has gradually expanded over the years, and with growth, their charming stores and local businesses have become more prominent. Among these, Country Corner Dairy stands out as a notable destination for those interested in authentic Amish products and culture.
Located conveniently with clear signage and easily accessible via Google Maps, Country Corner Dairy is one of the more prominent Amish-run establishments in the area. When I arrived just before closing time, I noticed traditional Lancaster-style buggies with gray-topped canopies parked outside, hinting at the community’s roots from the Amish in St. Mary’s County, Maryland—an area originally populated by Lancaster County Amish. This store is often referred to as a “cheese factory,” but in reality, it offers a diverse array of food items, crafts, and household goods, making it a versatile shopping destination.
During my visit on December 23rd, I observed the store’s holiday hours, noting that it would be closed on Christmas, New Year’s Day, and Second Christmas (December 26). The store’s welcoming interior and inviting signage set the tone for a delightful shopping experience. Let’s delve into what makes Country Corner Dairy a unique spot to visit.
Inside Country Corner Dairy
While the name suggests a focus on dairy products, the store offers much more than just milk, cheese, and yogurt. Inside, you’ll find an impressive selection of canned goods, jams, jellies, handcrafted crafts, and even some gently used or dented items—perfect for bargain hunters.
One feature that immediately caught my eye was the skylights installed in the ceiling. These large square openings allow natural sunlight to illuminate the store—an eco-friendly, electricity-free lighting method that’s quite common in Amish businesses. The exterior architecture also showcases these light intakes, highlighting the community’s traditional building practices.
Among the local specialties, I discovered a collection of jams and jellies, including a particularly intriguing Peach Jalapeno Jam. I picked up a jar as a holiday gift for my brother, curious about its flavor profile. The jar’s aesthetic appeal was undeniable, and I look forward to trying it soon.
Of course, the dairy section is extensive, featuring a variety of cheeses, fresh milk, and yogurt. One type that stands out is Skyr, an Icelandic-style yogurt known for its thick consistency and mild flavor—an excellent addition to any health-conscious diet.
Other notable products include sweet Lebanon Bologna—an Amish specialty I enjoy for sandwiches—and a range of products from larger Amish-style producers in Ohio and Pennsylvania, such as Walnut Creek Foods. I also found canned beets from Walnut Creek and Mrs. Miller’s noodles, which are staples in many Amish households.
Engaging with the Owner
During my visit, I had the pleasure of speaking with Aaron Fisher, the friendly owner of Country Corner Dairy. He explained that along with three local farmers, he established the store in 2023, aiming to bring quality Amish products directly to the community and visitors alike.
Besides the offerings in-store, they also sell baked goods on Fridays and Saturdays—unfortunately, not available during my Monday visit, which was a bit of a disappointment. However, I did sample some homemade chocolates and peanut butter treats, which were delightful. Additionally, they carry maple syrup sourced from Upstate New York, available in various sizes, including gallons and half-gallons.
Curious about their connections, I asked Aaron if they maintained ties with the Lowville Amish community in New York. He confirmed that they do—using the term “back-and-forth” to describe their fellowship with neighboring Amish communities, which can span great distances. Interestingly, I mispronounced the town’s name, saying it as “Low-ville,” but Aaron pronounced it more like “Lahw-ville,” prompting me to wonder if it’s a regional accent or just a local pronunciation.
Understanding the origins of Amish products offers valuable insight into their community relationships. Many stores source items from specific Amish communities, reflecting their church fellowship and mutual support networks.
Other Non-Edible Goods
Beyond edibles, the store features a variety of handcrafted and household items, including woven baskets, scarves, small furniture pieces, and wooden decorative items. A closer look at the handmade baby quilts reveals the craftsmanship and attention to detail that define Amish textile work. These items add charm and authenticity to the shopping experience, making it more than just a grocery stop.
Visiting Country Corner Dairy
I left the store feeling satisfied with my visit. While it may not be as expansive or deli-focused as other Virginia Amish markets like Walker Valley Market or Pineview Bulk Food and Deli, it offers a warm, friendly environment with high-quality products at reasonable prices. The baked goods, I am sure, are excellent—and I plan to visit again on a weekend to sample them properly.
If you wish to visit, here are the essential details:
Country Corner Dairy
3005 County Line Road
Cullen, VA 23934
Hours:
- Monday-Friday: 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM
- Saturday: 8:00 AM to 3:00 PM
- Sunday: Closed
Remember, baked goods are available on Fridays and Saturdays. If you visit, mention that you heard about this place from Erik in Raleigh—there’s a good chance Aaron will remember! Feel free to share your experience and thoughts afterward, as it helps support local Amish businesses and preserves their unique culture.