Understanding Rubber Cement and Barge Cement: Key Differences and Uses
Rubber cement is renowned for providing a highly flexible adhesive bond that can be peeled away easily with bare hands, making it ideal for applications requiring temporary or adjustable adhesion. It requires moisture during application to dry and bond effectively. Conversely, barge cement offers a strong, flexible, and permanent bond that is not easily removable once set.
When applying rubber cement to surfaces, they are typically pressed together with gentle pressure to achieve bonding. Barge cement, however, has a designated dry time—this is the period needed for the solvents to evaporate, ensuring optimal adhesion. Failing to allow sufficient dry time can hinder proper bonding. In some cases, using a hairdryer on the surfaces can accelerate the drying process because barge cement contains flammable solvents that respond well to heat, facilitating a stronger, more secure bond.
What is Barge Cement?
Barge cement is a versatile, multipurpose adhesive celebrated for its robust bonding capabilities across a wide array of materials, including leather, plastic, and wood. It is formulated with a neoprene base, free from toluene, and is solvent-based. This composition ensures a durable and flexible bond suitable for demanding industrial applications.
Applying barge cement involves a drying phase—wait long enough for the solvents to evaporate before pressing surfaces together. If surfaces are bonded prematurely, the bond may be weak. To enhance bond strength, heat can be applied carefully using a hairdryer, as the adhesive is flammable and responds well to heat activation. After drying, barge cement dries clear, leaving no visible residue, which makes it ideal for bonding porous materials like wood, rubber, glass, and certain plastics. It is essential to work in well-ventilated areas away from heat sources to prevent fire hazards and inhalation of toxic fumes.
What is Rubber Cement?
Rubber cement is an adhesive formulated from elastic polymers, typically latex, dissolved in solvents such as acetone, hexane, or toluene. Its water-based formula, stabilized with ammonia, allows it to dry quickly and form a flexible, yet strong, bond. The addition of small amounts of alcohol further stabilizes the mixture.
Widely favored in arts and crafts, rubber cement is particularly valued for its damage-free removal, making it suitable for paper projects and artwork. It acts as an erasable marking fluid in pens because it can be peeled off easily without damaging the paper or leaving residue. However, its low pH can lead to deterioration of photographs over time. Due to its chemical composition, rubber cement poses hazards such as flammability and potential inhalation risks, especially because it contains toluene. Therefore, it is recommended to use rubber cement in well-ventilated areas and away from heat sources to minimize health risks.
Similarities Between Barge Cement and Rubber Cement
Drying Adhesives
Both adhesives are classified as drying adhesives because their effectiveness depends on the evaporation of solvents. They require a specific drying period—approximately five minutes—after application before the surfaces can be bonded securely. Rubber cement, like barge cement, exhibits a shiny or less wet appearance before setting, indicating readiness for bonding.
Toxic Odors
Both adhesives emit strong, potentially hazardous fumes due to chemicals like acetone, heptane, isoprene alcohol, and trichloroethane. Proper ventilation and protective gear such as respirators are recommended when working with either glue to avoid inhaling toxic vapors.
Flammability
As solvent-based adhesives, both rubber cement and barge cement are highly flammable. They release vapors that can ignite easily when exposed to open flames or heat sources. Using these adhesives in open, well-ventilated areas minimizes fire risk.
Water Resistance
Once fully dried, both adhesives display high resistance to water, ensuring the bonds remain intact even in moist environments. This water resistance makes them suitable for various applications where exposure to moisture is expected.
Comparison of Barge Cement and Rubber Cement
Water-Based vs. Solvent-Based
Barge cement is classified as a solvent-based adhesive, employing organic solvents that give it a light yellow to transparent appearance upon application. Its main components include acrylic and water-based agents designed for high durability. In contrast, rubber cement is water-based, often appearing milky white when applied, and is considered more environmentally friendly. However, rubber cement generally offers less durability in harsh conditions compared to solvent-based adhesives like barge cement.
Dry Time
Dry time refers to the duration required for an adhesive to reach optimal bonding strength after application. Rubber cement typically requires about five minutes to dry before surfaces are pressed together, as it needs time for solvents to evaporate. Barge cement, however, necessitates a longer dry period—sometimes 15 minutes or more—to allow the solvents to fully evaporate, ensuring a strong, permanent bond. Accelerating the drying process with heat can be effective but must be done cautiously due to flammability.
Toxicity
The presence of toluene in rubber cement poses health risks, including respiratory issues and the potential development of asthma with prolonged exposure. Rubber cement should always be used in well-ventilated areas, and protective measures should be taken. Barge cement lacks toluene, making it a safer alternative from a health perspective, especially for prolonged or frequent use.
Functionality
Barge cement is suitable for bonding various hard and flexible materials, providing a strong, durable, and permanent bond. It is ideal for industrial applications but less suitable for papercraft or projects where repositioning is desired. Rubber cement, on the other hand, is perfect for arts and crafts involving paper, as it offers a temporary bond that can be easily repositioned or removed without damage.
Time Factor and Application
Barge cement requires a longer dry time and is best applied when a permanent, robust bond is needed. Rubber cement can be applied and bonded immediately, making it convenient for projects requiring quick assembly and easy removal.
Ease of Removal
Due to its chemical formulation, barge cement is difficult to remove once set and may require solvents like acetone for removal. Rubber cement, by design, can be peeled off easily without chemical solvents, making it suitable for temporary applications and art projects.
Recommended Uses of Barge Cement
Applying to Flexible Objects
Barge cement is engineered to provide high resilience and tensile strength, making it suitable for bonding flexible materials and components in various industries. It is extensively used where durable, elastic bonds are required, such as in manufacturing moving parts or flexible assemblies.
Shoe Repair
For repairing footwear, especially the insole and outsole, barge cement is an excellent choice. Its ease of application with a brush, combined with its strong, flexible bond after drying, ensures long-lasting repairs. Apply an adequate layer of cement to the affected areas, allow proper drying, and then clamp the parts together for optimal adhesion.
Use in Diverse Environments
Unlike adhesives containing toluene, barge cement is environmentally friendly and safe for use in various settings, including enclosed or humid environments. Its formulation eliminates the health risks associated with toxic fumes, making it suitable for professional, industrial, and hobbyist applications.
- Buy Barge Cement ONLINE
When to Use Rubber Cement
For Paper Craft and Artwork
Rubber cement excels in paper crafts, where quick adhesion and damage-free removal are essential. Its pressure-sensitive nature allows for repositioning during assembly, making it ideal for artistic projects, scrapbooking, and mounting photographs. Rubber cement’s flexibility and ease of removal make it a preferred choice for delicate or temporary applications.
For Jobs Requiring Temporary Bonding
Because rubber cement does not withstand extreme strain, it is suitable for projects where the bond needs to be temporary or easily removable. It is often used in situations where adjustments are anticipated or for initial assembly stages before permanent bonding.
Which Adhesive is Better? A Summary
Overall, barge cement is considered superior for demanding, industrial, and permanent bonding tasks due to its strong, durable, and water-resistant properties. It is solvent-based, offering faster application and higher resistance to environmental factors. Rubber cement, however, remains a favorite in arts and crafts because of its flexibility, ease of removal, and suitability for paper-based projects.
Choosing between the two depends on your specific application requirements, safety considerations, and environmental factors.
Leave a Reply